The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) is an amazing business laptop with a lightweight form factor and a stunning display. But it comes at a premium price point compared to competing laptops, and it’s not the ideal machine when you’re looking for sustained CPU performance. Show
Lenovo’s ThinkPad X1 Carbon may be one of the best business laptops you can get your hands on. This isn’t your average laptop. It’s a high-end product that combines the latest Intel hardware with a lot of extra touches that make it just nice to use. It incorporates carbon fiber to make it more lightweight and durable. Of course, it also costs more than a typical thin and light machine, and the CPU performance isn’t the fastest under heavy pressure. This latest version features a 14th-generation Intel Core Ultra 7 processor, bringing the ThinkPad X1 Carbon into the Meteor Lake era. It also has some keyboard tweaks that will make it less odd to use if you’re new to ThinkPads. But it’s still got the classic design touches you might be looking for from a ThinkPad, including that classic red “nub.” If you’re looking for a high-end business laptop with lots of thoughtful touches — or, heck, if you’re looking for an awesome consumer laptop at this price point and gaming isn’t a priority for you — this might just be the laptop you should buy. But, while the laptop feels snappy and is a generally a joy to use for day-to-day tasks, with a great keyboard and a beautiful screen, the benchmarks confirm that this is a thin-and-light laptop that makes some performance trade-offs to achieve its sleek form factor and unusually light weight. Looking for more options? Check out PCWorld’s roundup of the best laptops. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): SpecsThe Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon is available in a variety of configurations. You always get a speedy Intel Core Ultra 7 155H processor and Intel Arc graphics. It starts at $2042 on Lenovo’s website for a machine with 16 GB of RAM and a 512 GB SSD. The machine we reviewed costs $2703 and included 32 GB of RAM, a 1 TB SSD, and a micro-SIM slot for cellular connectivity. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon features two Thunderbolt (USB-C) ports as well as two classic USB-A ports. The ThinkPad charges via one of these Thunderbolt ports, and they’re both located on the left. As far as the two USB-A ports, one is located on each side of the machine, giving you more flexibility. There’s also a convenient HDMI port and an audio jack on the right side of the machine. If you’re looking for an SD card reader, Ethernet, or more USB ports, you’ll need a dongle. That’s not surprising, but it is something to be aware of if you’re looking for a business laptop with the most possible built-in ports. Our review model came with a 2.8k OLED display without a touch screen, but Lenovo also offers the option of a touch-enabled OLED display and lower-resolution 1920×1200 displays. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) also packs an Intel Evo Edition sticker, which Intel is applying to higher-end laptops the provide the “best experience.”
Lenovo has also offered versions of its previous ThinkPad X1 Carbon laptops that come with Linux preinstalled instead of Windows. I’ve long considered this one of the best Linux laptops you can buy, and it’s great to see PC manufacturers offering the option. Lenovo tells me a configuration of the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) with Linux should be available around mid-March. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): Design and build quality IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Lenovo’s line of ThinkPad laptops has a classic style. It’s not gaudy, but I don’t consider it boring either. It’s a sleek, matte black design with red highlights, including the classic red ThinkPad “nub” in the center of the keyboard. On the back of the laptop’s screen, the dot in the red “i” in ThinkPad lights up when the laptop is on. It combines retro touches with a sleek, modern design. Bezels are small, but the webcam “bar” above the top of the laptop’s screen juts out a bit, giving you a nice handhold to grip when you’re opening the laptop. Build quality feels excellent: Lenovo uses “aerospace-grade carbon fiber” as well as recycled aluminum and magnesium. The matte finish on the body of the laptop feels almost “rubbery” – in a good way! It’s not smooth metal, and it doesn’t get cold to the touch. It’s not creaky plastic, either. It feels nice. That material doesn’t just give the ThinkPad X1 a distinct feel: It also makes the machine extremely light. The ThinkPad Carbon X1 weighs just 2.42 pounds. Dell says the 2024 model of the Dell XPS 13 laptop will start at 2.6 pounds. The latest version of the HP Spectre 360, another laptop we like a lot, weighs in at 3.43 pounds. Of course, the ThinkPad Carbon X1 is more expensive than these competing laptops, but you’re getting something nice for the extra money. Lenovo says the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) “aspires to be one of the toughest in its class” and is graded to MIL-STD 810H standards. It should be more durable, rugged, and resistant to extreme environments than your average laptop. The Lenovo X1 Carbon can lie flat, too — something that’s very convenient for use on airplanes, for example. The software is nice and clean, too: You won’t find a lot of included apps automatically starting with your PC. Lenovo bundles a few useful utilities, but it’s a very nice setup that gets out of your way. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): Keyboard and trackpadIDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman The ThinkPad’s full-size keyboard feels spacious and nice to type on, with plenty of travel for a laptop keyboard, and it’s nice and quiet. The keyboard has an optional backlight with white lighting. There’s one huge change here for ThinkPads: Lenovo has put the Ctrl key in the bottom left corner of the keyboard and the Fn key to the right of the Ctrl key. This is how most other laptops do it, but ThinkPads did it their own way in the past. As someone who’s used ThinkPads now and then but has spent most of his time with other laptops, I think this is great – if you’re new to ThinkPads, this is the way you’ll expect it to work. If you are an experienced ThinkPad user, it may be weird: But good news, you can swap the keys back around in the included “Lenovo Commercial Vantage” software under Input & Accessories. The glass trackpad feels excellent, and it features three buttons above it – the third button in the middle can function as a middle click if you change a setting in the ThinkPad’s TrackPoint software, but it scrolls around web pages by default. It’s nice to have those physical buttons. As far as the TrackPoint, affectionately known as the “red nub,” it’s definitely here! You can place your finger on the nub and apply pressure to move the mouse cursor around on your screen. It seems to work well, but I’ve never been a nub person. If you love it, good news: It’s here! If you don’t use it, it doesn’t get in the way, and it adds a lot of visual flair and ThinkPad style to the keyboard. One thing I’ve noticed as I get up to speed with the ThinkPad X1’s keyboard is it beeping at me. All keyboards can only handle it when you press so many keys at a time, and they’ll miss some of your keypresses. If you press too many keys at once, the ThinkPad will beep at you to let you know. So, while it seemed like the problem was I was typing too quickly, the problem was that I was actually lifting my fingers from the keys too slowly. The beeping is something you can disable if you like,, but it’s an interesting feature because the ThinkPad is alerting you that you may have lost a keyboard input – something that could be extremely good to know when coding, writing, or doing anything else on your computer. As I quickly got used to the keyboard and became faster at lifting my fingers from the keys, I wasn’t encountering the beeping so much anymore. (And when you hear that beep, remember that the average laptop wouldn’t beep – it would just miss some of your keypresses. The ThinkPad’s beeping is very helpful.) Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): Display and speakersIDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) has a 14-inch display. The model we reviewed came with a 2.4k (2880×1800) OLED display with a 120Hz refresh rate and HDR support: HDR True Black 500 and Dolby Vision. Lenovo also says it’s Eye Safe-certified to reduce blue light. It’s a 16:10 display which, to me, is essential for productivity on a laptop: You get a lot of vertical space for getting work done. The OLED display looks great – it’s beautiful, vibrant, and plenty bright. I’ve been using a laptop with a lower-resolution display lately – one without an OLED display – and the ThinkPad X1 Carbon’s display was an immediate huge upgrade as soon as I laid my eyes on it. Our model didn’t have a touch screen, but Lenovo offers touch-screen models. As usual, we’d expect the touch screen to require more power and cut the laptop’s battery life a bit. Lenovo also offers models with lower-resolution, non-OLED displays – to be precise, they have full HD (1920×1200) IPS displays. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) features an interesting speaker setup: Lenovo has placed the speakers below the keyboard. Lenovo says those upward-firing speakers offer a great experience in Dolby Atmos content – sort of like how Dolby Atmos-enabled soundbars feature upward-firing speakers. (While the speakers are below the keyboard, Lenovo says the keyboard is still spill-resistant.) Lenovo describes the speaker audio as “clear and clean.” They sound pretty good as far as integrated speakers go: Speech is clear, so this will work well for online calls and listening to YouTube videos. I streamed the Dolby Atmos-enabled Dune on Netflix and the audio wasn’t bad; you could certainly watch a movie and have a decent experience as far as laptop audio goes. But these are still integrated speakers on a lightweight laptop: You aren’t going to get a lot of booming bass, and this isn’t going to compete with a serious external speaker setup or solid pair of headphones. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): Webcam, microphone, biometricsIDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Lenovo’s ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) features a 1080p webcam on a bar above the display. It also includes a Windows Hello-compatible IR camera for facial logins. There’s a physical privacy shutter next to the webcam, and when you slide it, you’ll see a red dot appear in place of the webcam – a nice clear sign the webcam is disabled. That privacy shutter doesn’t block the Windows Hello webcam, so you can still sign into your laptop with facial recognition even while blocking the standard webcam. Thanks to the neural processing unit (NPU,) this laptop supports Windows Studio Effects for webcams: Features like Automatic framing to keep your face in the frame as you move around, Eye contact to make it look like you’re looking at the webcam even when you aren’t, and Background blur for blurring your background. They work fine, and it’s cool that they happen on your PC so they’re compatible with any video application, but they’re not life changing. They’re still nice to have — especially Eye contact for video calls. The webcam is fine, but I wouldn’t call it excellent. It will serve you well in online meetings. Still, a higher-resolution camera would be nice to see in future high-end business laptops at this price point. I have been in a lot of online meetings, and the ThinkPad X1’s webcam beats the video quality I see most people using. So that’s good news: You may be at the top of the pack – unless someone has an external 4K webcam, which of course you could plug into this or any other laptop anyway. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) also features dual-array microphones paired with Dolby Voice technology. Lenovo says they “do a great job of picking up voices” and suppressing noise, and they did sound great – this is the kind of laptop you can use for online calls without plugging in an external microphone, and everyone will be able to hear you clearly. I had no urge to plug in an external microphone. In addition to the Windows Hello-enabled IR camera for facial recognition sign-in, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) features a fingerprint sensor near the bottom-right corner of the keyboard, to the left of the arrow keys. This isn’t a key you can press down – it’s a sensor you rest your finger over. Like the Windows Hello-enabled camera, it works well, giving you multiple biometric sign-in options. Unlike on the previous generation model, the fingerprint reader is no longer integrated into the power button. The power button has moved “off the keyboard” and onto the right side of the laptop, near the headphone jack. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): ConnectivityIDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Business laptops generally feature more connectivity options than garden-variety thin and lightweight machines. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) features Wi-Fi 6E connectivity. Lenovo tells me there should be some ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) configurations with Wi-Fi 7 available in mid-March. Windows 11 doesn’t even support Wi-Fi 7 yet — Microsoft only just added Wi-Fi 7 support in an Insider build of Windows 11 that’s currently being tested. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) also features Bluetooth 5.3 hardware — again, the industry is up to Bluetooth 5.4. Both Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3 are fine. You almost certainly don’t have a Wi-Fi 7 router yet, and you may never notice the omission of Wi-Fi 7. But it’s important to note the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) hasn’t gone bleeding-edge with future-proof connectivity options across all ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) configurations — still, if that’s important to you, it sounds like Lenovo will have a solution with upgraded, more bleeding-edge radios soon. In addition, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon goes above and beyond with an optional nano-SIM slot — our review unit had one, but we didn’t test the cellular speeds. You have the option to add cellular connectivity to your laptop, giving you an always-on internet connection – anywhere with a cellular signal, anyway – without the hassle of tethering to your smartphone or using a mobile hotspot. That’s still a pretty rare feature on laptops, and it’s the kind of thing that sets high-end business laptops like the X1 Carbon apart. (Of course, you will need to pay for a cellular plan through a cellular carrier for this — there’s no free lunch.) As far as ports, you get two Thunderbolt 4 ports — compatible with USB-C — on the left. Bear in mind that the ThinkPad X1 Carbon charges through one of them, so one of them will be in-use while charging and you’ll always have to plug the charger in on the left side of the laptop. Additionally, there are two classic USB-A ports — specifically, USB-A 3.2 Gen 1 ports — one on each side. You’ll also find a combo audio jack for headphones and a microphone, and a convenient HDMI 2.1 port on the right. There’s also a Kensington Nano security slot for physically locking the laptop. You won’t find a built-in Ethernet port, an SD card reader, or anything else here. For more ports, you’ll need a dongle. There are business laptops that include more built-in ports, but you should expect them to be thicker and heavier than the ThinkPad X1 Carbon – the ThinkPad X1 Carbon hews a little closer to the thin-and-light variety, and it isn’t the kind of beefy business laptop that packs the maximum number of possible ports. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): PerformanceThe Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon includes Intel’s new Core Ultra 7 155H, which has 16 cores: Six performance cores, eight efficient cores, and another two low-power efficient cores. It’s designed to provide a lot of performance when you need it and long battery life in day-to-day tasks. Our review model came with 32GB of LPDDR5X memory and a 1TB PCIe NVMe SSD. The laptop includes Intel Arc integrated graphics. IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Our first test, PCMark 10, is designed to benchmark the system’s overall performance. The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) delivered a strong score, clocking in a little above some other recent laptops with the same Core Ultra 155H chip, like the Dell XPS 16 9640. Digging into the results, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) scored particularly well on PCMark’s App Startup benchmark, implying speedy storage may be bringing up its performance. IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Next, we ran Cinebench R20, a multithreaded CPU test. Here, the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon fell behind those other Core Ultra 155H laptops, while it ran ahead of some laptops with Intel and AMD chips released last year. That’s not hugely surprising — those competitors that beat the ThinkPad X1 Carbon are 16-inch laptops, while this is a 14-inch laptop. The ThinkPad is likely held back by its cooling. While the laptop’s fans normally aren’t audible, they spin up under load, with warm air blowing up through the keyboard. It’s not uncomfortable or too warm at all, but the laptop’s performance is likely limited by its cooling setup. IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman We also ran a Handbrake video encoding test. This is another multithreaded CPU benchmark that demands sustained CPU performance. The results showed the laptop’s limitations when it comes to sustained CPU utilization, with the ThinkPad needing 1,835 seconds — that’s over 30 minutes — to encode our test file. Combined with the PCMark benchmark above, that suggests the ThinkPad has solid “burst” CPU performance but struggles with the cooling needed to deliver it over a longer period of time. What do we make of this? Well, a laptop this lightweight and compact isn’t going to have the fastest CPU performance. It’s important to look just beyond the specific CPU in the laptop: Cooling is such an important factor that larger laptops with the same CPU and better cooling will deliver better performance. This isn’t the kind of machine that will deliver the highest CPU performance under sustained high demand. That’s not what it’s optimized for. It’s optimized for being thin, light, and snappy in day-to-day computer use. IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman We also run 3Dmark’s Time Spy benchmark to get an idea of the GPU performance. Results here were as expected. The Intel Arc graphics here are a huge leap from the previous-generation Intel Iris Xe graphics. However, Intel’s Arc graphics still don’t come anywhere close to the performance of a discrete NVIDIA GeForce RTX GPU. This isn’t a gaming laptop, but it’s great to see Intel’s graphics performance improve. You could do some gaming on it in a pinch! Overall, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) feels snappy in day-to-day use. I’ll be honest, I had a very positive perception of the performance based on using the laptop for day-to-day. But, owing to its thin-and-light nature, this laptop isn’t a CPU speed demon for workloads that use a lot of CPU power over an extended period of time. That much is clear. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): Battery lifeBattery life was reasonable, and it should be plenty of juice to make it through a workday — assuming you’re not using extremely demanding applications all day. With its 57-watt-hour battery, the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) provided competitive battery life. The only laptops that surpass it in our comparison below are heavier laptops with bigger batteries. IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman IDG / Chris Hoffman Our standard battery test loops a 4K copy of the Tears of Steel film with the laptop’s display set to 250 nits, keyboard backlighting off, and airplane mode turned on. The ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) ran for an average of 632 minutes — that’s just over ten and a half hours. While other laptops beat the ThinkPad X1 Carbon, the size of the battery is a big factor. For example, the 16-inch Dell XPS 16 delivered 974 minutes of battery life in our testing, for example — that’s another three hours. But it has a 99-watt-hour battery and weighs 5.03 pounds. It’s more than twice as heavy as the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12). The HP Pavillion Plus had longer battery life, but it also has a larger battery — a 68 watt-hour battery, unlike the 57-watt-hour battery here — so it’s heavier. There’s no free lunch: The smaller the battery, the lighter the laptop — but the less the battery life. The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon has an OLED display, so it achieves longer battery life in our test thanks to all the black displayed on the screen in this test. Lenovo tries to maximize that advantage by setting Windows 11 to dark mode out of the box, too. Ten and a half hours of battery life is a sold number, but you almost certainly aren’t going to see it in day-to-day use. Laptops are very optimized as playing local video files like this. This is a best case scenario for the laptop: Turn on Wi-Fi, fire up some applications, and start using applications with bright-white backgrounds, and the laptop is going to go through battery power faster. Still, it’s a great way to compare battery life between laptops. Is this enough battery life? Well, that depends — if you want to be away from an outlet for an extended workday, perhaps you’ll want a heavier laptop with bigger battery. But this ThinkPad charges quickly, and it’s rare I see people go an entire eight-hour workday with their laptop on the entire time and without ever going near an outlet. Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12): ConclusionThe Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) is a beautiful machine for getting work done. It’s nicely constructed, extremely lightweight, and great to type on, with a beautiful display and solid battery life that seems like it could only be improved by packing a bigger, heavier battery into the laptop. But it’s expensive. You’re paying extra for a lot of thoughtful touches, but you can spend less money and get a great experience. I’ve always liked the HP Spectre x360 series, and as I write this, the HP Spectre x360 starts at $1,099 on HP’s website — $1,000 less than the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12.) Meanwhile, Dell says its 2024 XPS 13 laptop will start at $1,299. You can never “have it all,” and the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12) makes some noticeable tradeoffs with CPU performance to achieve its sleek form factor. Those trade-offs reveal themselves under our benchmarks that hit the CPU hard over a long period of time — like our video-encoding benchmarks — and you’ll notice them if you have a CPU-heavy like that. But you probably aren’t looking at this machine if you want the workhorse laptop with maximum CPU performance. If you spend a lot of time in browsers, Office documents, and online meetings, you may enjoy the rest of the laptop so much that the CPU performance may not be a factor. The lightest, smallest laptops just won’t have the best performance in extreme situations. That’s how it is The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon is a great machine. But how much extra is that premium experience worth it to you — perhaps you’d like a cheaper option? Is the slow CPU performance under load a problem for your workflow — perhaps you’d like a larger laptop with the same CPU? These are questions only you can answer. Still, I was blown away by the ThinkPad X1 Carbon (Gen 12.) I’ve loved using it. Between the price and performance, it’s not for everyone — but maybe it’s the ideal machine for you. Chris Hoffman is the author of Windows Intelligence, a free email newsletter that brings the latest Windows PC news, trips, and tricks to inboxes each week. He's also the former editor-in-chief of How-To Geek and a veteran tech journalist whose work has appeared in The New York Times, PCMag, Reader's Digest, and other publications. Why is the X1 carbon so good?The Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 11 (2023) and the Dell XPS 13 Plus (2022) are both high-end ultraportable laptops that provide a premium user experience. However, the ThinkPad X1 is better overall because it has a better keyboard and webcam as well as a wider port selection.nullLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 11 (2023) Laptop Review - RTINGS.comwww.rtings.com › laptop › reviews › thinkpad-x1-carbon-gen-11-2023null How long do Lenovo X1 Carbon last?ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 11 battery life So, battery life should be around five or six hours, as we experienced when we reviewed last year's model. Of course, the way you use your ThinkPad X1 Carbon will change that. If you always have the screen at high brightness, you can't expect long battery life.nullDoes the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 11 have good battery ...www.xda-developers.com › thinkpad-x1-carbon-gen-11-battery-lifenull What is the difference between Lenovo X1 and X1 Carbon?The X1 Carbon and X1 Yoga are also similarly sized in width and depth with small side bezels but rather bezels along the top and bottom, and they're both 0.59 inches thick. The X1 Carbon is lighter than the X1 Yoga, at 2.4 pounds versus 2.99 pounds, thanks to the latter's heavier metal chassis.nullThinkPad X1 Yoga vs. ThinkPad X1 Carbon - Digital Trendswww.digitaltrends.com › computing › thinkpad-x1-carbon-vs-thinkpad-x1...null What type of SSD is in the Lenovo X1 Carbon Gen 3?Re:X1 3rd Gen SSD upgrade The Gen 3 Carbon was a different beast. It supports either a SATA or PCIe/AHCI SSD. It does not support an NVMe drive. Those AHCI drives are rare and expensive.nullX1-3rd-Gen-SSD-upgrade - LENOVO COMMUNITYforums.lenovo.com › ThinkPad-X-Series-Laptops › X1-3rd-Gen-SSD-upgr...null |
