Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

Read Online (Free) relies on page scans, which are not currently available to screen readers. To access this article, please contact JSTOR User Support . We'll provide a PDF copy for your screen reader.

With a personal account, you can read up to 100 articles each month for free.

Get Started

Already have an account? Log in

Monthly Plan

  • Access everything in the JPASS collection
  • Read the full-text of every article
  • Download up to 10 article PDFs to save and keep
$19.50/month

Yearly Plan

  • Access everything in the JPASS collection
  • Read the full-text of every article
  • Download up to 120 article PDFs to save and keep
$199/year

Log in through your institution

Purchase a PDF

Purchase this article for $15.00 USD.

Purchase this issue for $20.00 USD. Go to Table of Contents.

How does it work?

  1. Select a purchase option.
  2. Check out using a credit card or bank account with PayPal.
  3. Read your article online and download the PDF from your email or your account.

journal article

William James's Theory of Emotion

Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society

Vol. 5, No. 2 (Spring, 1969)

, pp. 67-89 (23 pages)

Published By: Indiana University Press

https://www.jstor.org/stable/40319566

Read and download

Log in through your school or library

Alternate access options

For independent researchers

Read Online

Read 100 articles/month free

Subscribe to JPASS

Unlimited reading + 10 downloads

Purchase article

$15.00 - Download now and later

Journal Information

Transactions has been the premier peer-reviewed journal specializing in the history of American philosophy since its founding in 1965. Although it is named for the founder of American pragmatism, American philosophers of all schools and periods, from the colonial to the recent past, are extensively discussed. The journal regularly includes essays, and every significant book published in the field is discussed in a review essay. A subscription includes membership in the Charles S. Peirce Society. Membership in the Charles S. Peirce Society is activated by subscribing to the journal and selecting Join Society.

Publisher Information

Indiana University Press was founded in 1950 and is today recognized internationally as a leading academic publisher specializing in the humanities and social sciences. As an academic press, our mandate is to serve the world of scholarship and culture as a professional, not-for-profit publisher. We publish books and journals that will matter 20 or even a hundred years from now – titles that make a difference today and will live on into the future through their reverberations in the minds of teachers and writers. IU Press's major subject areas include African, African American, Asian, cultural, Jewish and Holocaust, Middle East, Russian and East European, and women's and gender studies; anthropology, film, history, bioethics, music, paleontology, philanthropy, philosophy, and religion. The Press also features an extensive regional publishing program under its Quarry Books imprint. It is one of the largest public university presses, as measured by titles and income level.

Rights & Usage

This item is part of a JSTOR Collection.
For terms and use, please refer to our Terms and Conditions
Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society © 1969 Indiana University Press
Request Permissions

Emotion is a response of the whole organism involving physiological arousal ❤️, expressive behaviors🚶, and conscious experience 🤔

Theories of Emotion

Just like with motivation, there are tons of different theories of emotion. What we know, in general, is that our emotions helped us survive as well. They help us stay focused at stressful times and keep us alert at cautious times🚨.

Common Sense Theory

First, there was the common sense theory that said first you feel the emotion, and then the physiological response. An example of this would be, "I'm scared so I tremble."

This was like the instinct theory in motivation; it didn't really stick and make sense to other psychologists, so they came up with their own theories after it.

💡Tl;dr—Emotion -> Physiological response

James-Lange Theory

This theory said that emotion is the result of a physiological response, which in turn activates the emotion, which is the opposite of the common sense theory.

An example of this is, "we feel sad because we cry, angry because we tense up, and afraid because we tremble.”

Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

Image Courtesy of Pixorize.

💡Tl;dr—Physiological Response -> Emotion

Cannon-Bard Theory

With this theory, a stimulus activates the brain, which simultaneously triggers physiological responses and the subjective experience of emotion. Canon believed that the body's responses are too similar to be two separate things.

An example of this is, "my heart begins pounding as I feel fear.”

Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

Image Courtesy of Pixorize.

💡Tl;dr—Physiological Response + Emotion

Schachter-Singer Theory

The Schachter-Singer Theory, or Schachter 2 Factor Theory, brings cognition into emotion. When one senses physiological arousal, one does a cognitive appraisal by scanning their environment in order to determine the emotion that one is feeling.

An example of this is, "I am trembling because of the snake in the room. Therefore, I must be afraid."

Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

Image Courtesy of Pixorize.

💡Tl;dr—Physiological Response + Thoughts = Emotion

Zajonc-LeDoux

Zajonc and LeDoux believed that our emotional reactions were separate from our cognitive label on the situation.

They thought that some emotions, particularly those needed for our immediate survival (e.g., anger or rage), were quickly activated through a fast pathway, while other emotions (e.g., love) went through a slow pathway. Some embodied emotions happen instantly, without conscious appraisal.

An example of this is when you automatically get startled by a sound in the forest before labeling it as a threat. 

Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

Image Courtesy of Purdue.

Zajonc and LeDoux believed that not all emotional responses involve cognition.

Lazarus, Schachter, and Singer believed that memories, expectations, and interpretations always influence our emotional responses.

Lazarus

Cognitive appraisal of the environment leads us to activate physiological arousal and emotional experience.

An example of this is, “Is it dangerous or not? That sound is 'just the wind.'”

3 Primary Emotions (Evolution)

Our body's adaptive response motivates adaptive response for survival. These include fear, anger, and happiness.

Facial Expression and Emotions

Emotions are very similar, there are only subtle differences between them. They mainly differ in where the brain activates:

  • Fear and anger are both very similar, but fear provokes more activity💡 in our amygdala.

  • When we feel negative emotions, the right prefrontal cortex lights up. When we feel positive emotions, the left prefrontal cortex lights up.

Body language speaks volumes about your emotions.

  • We are really good at finding nonverbal threats. Angry faces, voices, and negative words tend to pop out to us.

  • We find it difficult to figure out who is lying. Sometimes, a polygraph is used to detect lies based on your body's physical response. Some people can mask their physical responses, so fMRIs are actually more effective when finding out who lies.

  • Women are better at reading emotional cues and are stereotyped as being gentle and emotional. Men, on the other hand, are stereotyped as being angry.

Culture

Research by Paul Ekman and his colleagues suggests that facial expressions are universal. No matter what, we can always detect happiness, sadness, shock, and fear on other people's faces.

Which theory proposed that we feel sorry because we cry...afraid because we tremble?

You could probably tell which emotion each person is displaying! Image Courtesy of UC Berkeley.

But cultures do differ in how much emotion they express. Usually, those in America and Europe seem to have more visible emotions, while those in Asia tend to hide their emotions. This is because of the individualistic culture that exists in America and Europe vs the collectivist culture that exists in Asia.

Facial Feedback Effect

The facial feedback effect isthe tendency of facial muscle states to trigger corresponding feelings. For example, smiling activates muscles that directly trigger the feeling of happiness.

If you were ever really upset and just smiled at yourself, you'd notice that you cheered up a little. Smiling is a natural therapy (smile therapy 😃).

🎥 Watch: AP PsychologyEmotion

Resources:

Which theory of emotion says we feel sorry because we cry afraid because we tremble?

As William James put it, “We feel sorry because we cry, angry because we strike, afraid because we tremble” (James, 1884, p. 190). A fundamental aspect of the James-Lange theory is that different patterns of arousal may create different emotional experiences.

Which theory of emotion suggests that you decide you are sad because you were crying?

The James-Lange Theory Rather, people feel sad because they cry, and, likewise, they feel happy because they smile. This theory suggests that different physiological states correspond to different experiences of emotion.

What does the James

The James-Lange theory of emotion postulates that emotions occur as a result of physical responses to events (physiological responses to stimuli directly cause subjective feelings).

What does William James's theory of emotions propose?

The James-Lange theory of emotion suggests that physical changes in the body happen first, which then leads to the experience of emotion. Essentially, emotions stem from your interpretation of your physical sensations.